Standardized testing and school accountability article pdf available in educational psychologist 452. Oct 24, 2015 the value of standardized tests taps into the national debate about the federal governments role in local schools. Nclb also led to an explosion of other standardized exams, including benchmark tests often administered 310 times per year. Highstakes testing is defined as tests to which positive or negative consequences are attacked phelps, 2005. I was always told that one bad apple will spoil the whole bunch. Phelps has devoted most of his working life to the world of education. Download defending standardized testing ebook free in pdf and epub format.
Annotated bibliography for standardized testing term paper. The education reform movement of the past 15 years has. It took my son less than an hour to take the pretest, and then i scored it, and there were instructions to tell me which level to give him for each subject. Broussard starts off her article by talking about her own son as a victim of standardized testing. Defending standardized testing lawrence erlbaum, march 2005. Standardized tests do not, and cannot, produce perfect measures, and no one claims that they can the measures are used, despite their imperfections, because in most situations in science as well as in life some information for making decisions is better than none. Nov 09, 2012 an 18yearold university of missouri freshman is making a documentary film about standardized testing after going through a bad personal experience with these exams. Phelps standardized testing has been called the greatest single social contribution of modern psychology, and it may be the most useful evaluation method available for human resourceintensive endeavors. Doing something about it would be jul 18, 2011 by richard p.
With microsoft certification, students can validate those skills. The school system is using standardized tests as a educational goal. The instructions also tell you that you can read over the recommended level, and if you think its too hard or too easy, you can pick. Most parents and teachers would argue that it is stressful and unnecessary, while state and government officials would argue that it is the only proper way to assess student knowledge accurately across the nation. Defending standardized testing minimizes the use of technical jargon so as to appeal to all who have a stake.
Annotated bibliography for standardized testing perry barr devry university annotated bibliography for standardized testing. Standardized testing is a subject that many people feel strongly about. The common critiques of highstakes testing include a significant reduction in. Fairtest annotated bibliography on testing and evaluating.
List of books and articles about standardized testing. Also includes sections on parents rights, testing terms and what you can do. External education expert on standardized testing for the learning scientists. For most of their history, however, standardized tests have been developed. Defending standardized testing 1st edition richard. Read standardized testing by richard p phelps, british journal of educational technology on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Defending standardized testing in searchworks catalog. The topics addressed are of interest to those concerned with the practice of measurement in field settings as well as researchers and. Kindle store go search countdown to black friday sale christmas. Mar 31, 2005 defending standardized testing by richard phelps, 9780805849110, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Explores the controversy surrounding standardized testing, discussing what a standardized test is, its history, and how testing affects teaching, along with arguments for and against testing. Phelps points out that much research conducted by education insiders on the topic is based on ideological preference or profound selfinterest. By bob peterson and monty neill assessment must consist of more.
Defending standardized testing download ebook pdf, epub. The standardized testing primer provides nonspecialists with a thorough overview of this controversial and complicated topic. Download pdf the effects of standardized testing free. Download pdf defending standardized testing free online. This book provides a balanced approach to understanding the role of testing in general and standardized testing in particular. A basic guide to standardized testing part 1 read christian homeschooling help and advice with home school resources and biblical guidance for home education. This article appears in the summer 2012 frauds, fallacies, fads, and fictions issue of academic questions volume 25, number 2 richard p. Pdf defending standardized testing download ebook for free. Relying on standardized tests for a placement of a student is unethical. In the following article, some of the positive and negative factors are discussed. Defending standardized testing by richard phelps books. A role play corporate executive you are an executive with a large and prosperous corporation. Characteristics of an effective student testing system. One teens standardized testing horror story and where it.
The list is designed to help in the identification of useful standardized tests. Testing concerns characteristics of an effective student. Defending standardized testing by richard phelps books on. The need for international guidelines the focus of the international test commission itc project is on guidelines for good test use and for encouraging best practice in assessment. Standardized testing, and its relative importance in educational section processes, have been discussed in detail in other works phelps, 2005. Psychologists and education practitioners have studied the effects of testing on student achievement i. Request pdf defending standardized testing the education reform movement of the past two decades has.
Microsoft it academy ita program provides students with the maintaining windows 8 technology skills they need to be successful in college and a career. Most reform efforts of the past couple of decades have attempted to raise academic standards and, often, testing is considered an essential component of the effort, necessary to prompt attainment of and gauge the extent to which standards are followed or attained. Thus, tests with written, oral, or otherwise constructed instructions or responses can be standardized. Pros and consuse of standardized tests page 2 cheating by teachers and administrators on standardized tests is rare, and not a reason to stop testing americas children. Defending standardized testing ebook written by richard phelps. Download and save all data of standardized testing primer book in one free pdf file. Defending standardized testing is an easy to read book, and the topics are even easier to follow. The war on standardized testing 4 first, he sketches the battle. The reliance on the tests contradicts a comprehensive system of accountability. The education reform movement of the past two decades has focused on raising academic standards. Some standards advocates attach a testing mechanism to gauge the extent to which high standards are actually accomplished, whereas some critics accuse the push for standards and testing of impeding reform and perpetuating inequality. Standardized testing has been called the greatest single social contribution of modern psychology, and it. I think this is mainly because of the logical and meaningful way the editor chose to organize the information. She is a parent another good point of view to analyze in this debate.
In your eyes, the schools have not been meeting these challenges very successfully. Click download or read online button to get tests testing and genuine school reform book now. A 32page, easytoread pamphlet which explains what standardized tests are, how they are used, whats wrong with them, and alternative ways to evaluate students. Phelps kill the messenger is perhaps the most thorough and authoritative work in defense of educational testing ever written. Defending standardized testing, 2005 online research. There is, perhaps, no issue more visible among current education reforms than standardized testing. The overemphasis on testing has led many teachers to eliminate projects and. Defending standardized testing request pdf researchgate. Standardized testing can be composed of multiplechoice questions, truefalse questions, essay questions, authentic assessments, or nearly any other form of assessment multiplechoice and truefalse items are often chosen because they can be given and scored inexpensively, quickly, and reliably through using special answer sheets that can be read by a computer or via computeradaptive tes. His most recent books are defending standardized testing psychology press, 2005, standardized testing primer peter lang, 2007, and correcting. Standardized testing is an extremely controversial area in the realm of public education today. Everyone invested in the success of american education. It eschews the statistical details of scaling, scoring, and measurement that are widely available in textbooks and at testing organization web sites, and instead describes standardized testing s social and political roles and its practical uses, who tests, when, where. It requires state testing of every student in grades 38 and once in high school, more than twice previous federal mandates.
Alternatives to standardized tests theres only one thing worse than requiring students to reduce all learning to a single correct answer, and that is reducing assessment and accountability to a single standardized test. Richard phelps describes the defenders, the critics, and the con. Paper the big test, nicholas lemann, farrar, straus and giroux, 1999. Standardized testing doesnt eliminate other methods of teaching in fact it from english na at douglas high school 03. Phelps in the 1980s, a young medical resident working in a highpoverty region of west virginia heard local school officials claim that their children scored above the national average on. We are just getting started in terms of solid research on standards, testing and accountability, said tom loveless, harvard professor and brookings institution education policy expert in 2003. Standardized tests only measure a portion of the students skills and learning. Reviews an easy to read bookthis book provides a balanced approach to understanding the role of testing in general and standardized testing in particular. It eschews the statistical details of scaling, scoring, and measurement that are widely. Then you can start reading kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer no kindle device.
Characteristics of an effective student testing system by. Phelps in the 1980s, a young medical resident working in a highpoverty region of west virginia heard local school officials claim that their children scored above the national average on standardized tests. Standardized testing doesnt eliminate other methods of. Defending standardized testing by richard phelps, 9780805849110, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Defending standardized testing by richard phelps nook. The association of american publishers test committee created this brochure, which is an executive summary of a book written by richard phelps entitled kill the messenger, to help policy makers.
Tests testing and genuine school reform download ebook. Includes bibliographic data, information about the author of the ebook, description of the ebook and other if such information is available. It eschews the statistical details of scaling, scoring, and measurement that are widely available in textbooks and at testing organization web sites, and instead describes standardized testing s social and political roles and its practical uses who tests, when. The obsession with highstakes standardized tests is stifling creativity and imagination in the classroom. An examination of the impact on those who fail by kearns, lauralee canadian journal of education, vol.
The demand for standardized student testing, richard phelps, educational measurement. The role and importance of standardized testing in the world of. Defending standardized testing minimizes the use of technical jargon so as to appeal to all who have a stake in american educational reform. The dissolution of 232 education knowledge richard p. Phelps a key component of our faith in progress is the corollary belief that our base of knowledge continually expands. Defending standardized testing 1st edition, kindle edition by richard phelps editor isbn. Read defending standardized testing online, read in. The role and importance of standardized testing in the.
Does the public believe that tests are a good way to learn about how well students are doing and to encourage them to do better. What does the american public think about standardized testing. Characteristics of an effective student testing system, educational horizons, 851, 1929. Standardized testing is one of the few means by which the public may. Nov 24, 2014 characteristics of an effective student testing system, educational horizons, 851, 1929. Nov 08, 2015 thus, tests with written, oral, or otherwise constructed instructions or responses can be standardized. There are a lot of problems in the country, problems that pose serious challenges to public education. It eschews the statistical details of scaling, scoring, and measurement that are widely available in textbooks and at testing organization web sites, and instead describes standardized testing s social and political roles and its practical uses. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read defending standardized testing. Educational horizons, v85 n1 p1929 fall 2006 the u. Standardized testing should be used to find the child with a learning disability and work with that child. Defending standardized testing minimizes the use of technical jargon so as to appeal to all who have a stake in american educational reform parents, policy makers, school board members, teachers, administrators, and measurement specialists. Annotated bibliography inequality standardized tests.
Limit class time spent on standardized tests cbs news. View standardized testing research papers on academia. She also shows the economics and corporative power behind standardized testing and the idea that standardized tests are largely about business in the education sector. It eschews the statistical details of scaling, scoring, and measurement that are widely available in textbooks and at testing organization web sites, and instead describes standardized testings social and political roles and its practical uses who tests, when. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Defending standardized testing pdf free download epdf. This book gives readers a balanced look at the issue of standardized testing in schools and its surrounding arguments. Everyone invested in the success of american education, from parents to policymakers, are affected by or concerned about educational testing. Enter your mobile number or email address below and well send you a link to download the free kindle app. Defending standardized testing this page intentionally left blank defending standardized testing edited by richar.
420 1416 799 649 317 258 1446 1395 991 574 1323 176 589 1005 282 798 419 718 840 181 814 401 1322 800 1182 855 563 1474 803 353 387 842 1425 797 1032 887 868